Manifest Bias

Curious how the BBC loves to ‘help’ us judge the effeciveness of the Tory government whether it is how it runs A&E or how successful it is in providing affordable homes for people.  Neither of those helpful sites were particularly accurate…the housing one suggested it was impossible to find an affordable home in London and yet one look at estate agent websites showed that was just not the case.  In light of which you have to roll your eyes at the latest wheeze from the BBC….tracking how the government is doing in fulfilling its manifesto commitments…

Daily and Sunday Politics manifesto tracker: Economy

We all know that the real world and the opposition of other political parties and pressure groups, one being the BBC itself, means that manifesto policies rarely become reality which is why you have to wonder at the reason behind the BBC move which can only highlight government ‘failure’ in the main, to varying degrees…will the BBC put such ‘failures’ in context and put the blame for the failure where it belongs or is this merely an exercise to provocatively ‘shame’ the government and call it a failure?

Here are two examples from the BBC’s most recent ‘tracking’….

Aim to achieve full employment in the UK

– Manifesto, page 18

• The government has not defined full employment, but William Beveridge, the architect of our welfare state, defined it as a workforce that was 3% unemployed. The current unemployment rate, as of February 2016, is 5.1%. The ONS employment rate – the proportion of working-age people in work – shows 74% of those aged 16-64 were in work in September-November 2015

Now that’s pretty misleading as we know that employment is at record levels in the UK...UK employment rate hits highest level since records began…..Why no mention of that context?

And what of this?….

Accept the recommendations of the Low Pay Commission that the National Minimum Wage should rise to £6.70 this autumn, on course for a Minimum Wage that will be over £8 by the end of the decade

– Manifesto, page 21

• In the Summer Budget 2015 George Osborne announced the introduction of a ‘National Living Wage’, starting at £7.20 and rising to £9 an hour by 2020

The BBC does mark that as a success for the government and yet they and the usual suspects have been attacking the policy as a failure for weeks now, in fact from the instant it was announced in the budget…despite the BBC never once, in my hearing, criticising Miliband for his ‘living wage’ policies and the ridiculous ‘predistribution’ plan.

Both examples illustrate how the BBC’s tracker is pretty much worthless as a trustworthy and valuable reference point as the tracker fails to report real world events and problems the government has in enacting its manifesto commitments.

Kind of suspect this arose from a brainstorm session for bored journos looking for something to write….preferably with the possibility of undermining the Tory government.  Make-work for those who don’t want to go out and do some real investigative journalism and dig up some real stories.