UN Climate Expert Finds More Rajendra Pachauri Inconsistencies

The Indian head of the U.N. climate change panel defended his position Friday even as further errors were identified in the panel's assessment of Himalayan glaciers, said Fox News.

 

Dr. Rajendra Pachauri dismissed calls for him to resign over the Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change’s retraction of a prediction that Himalayan glaciers could disappear by 2035.

 

But he admitted that there may have been other errors in the same section of the report, and said that he was considering whether to take action against those responsible.

 

“I know a lot of climate sceptics are after my blood, but I’m in no mood to oblige them,” he told The Times of London in an interview. “It was a collective failure by a number of people,” he said. “I need to consider what action to take, but that will take several weeks. It’s best to think with a cool head, rather than shoot from the hip.”

 

The IPCC’s 2007 report, which won it the Nobel Peace Prize, said that the probability of Himalayan glaciers “disappearing by the year 2035 and perhaps sooner is very high."

 

But it emerged last week that the forecast was based not on a consensus among climate change experts, but on a media interview with a single Indian glaciologist in 1999.

 

The IPCC admitted on Thursday that the prediction was “poorly substantiated” in the latest of a series of blows to the panel’s credibility.

 

Pachauri said that the IPCC’s report was the responsibility of the panel’s co-chairs at the time, both of whom have since moved on.

 

Meanwhile Richard North looks at the contradictions in the Pachauri camp. 

 

“RAJENDRA Pachauri … is, at best, one more blunder away from having to resign its (the IPCC’s) chairmanship.” That comes from the man we like to describe as the doyen of the warmists, Geoffrey Lean, writing in The Daily Telegraph.

 

Now doubt, we can help Dr R K on his way to a peaceful retirement as, with reckless abandon, he told The Hindu yesterday that the chances of the IPCC having made more errors in its benchmark 2007 report were “minimal if not non-existent“, even while admitting the “regrettable error” on the melting glaciers that has raised questions about its credibility.

 

Although retailed by the newspaper, the actual text comes from a press release, issued by TERI, offering in Q&A form the observations of R K Pachauri on the affair. This is helpfully reproduced, in full, on this website.

 

Not used by The Hindu are his comments on the funding obtained by TERI for its glaciology work, where this section is volunteered by Pachauri:

 

 Q8) There have been views that your institute has gained from the alarmist situation created to rope in projects worth billions of dollars?

 

Research on Climate Change in TERI goes as far as back as 1987 – before the IPCC had been formed. Our work on glaciers started two years ago recognising the need for greater field based data generation and modelling. The IPCC report has also pointed out the need for more research in these areas.

 

Q9) What is TERI’s research on Glaciers?

 

 The project on Himalayan glacier quoted by the media (Hi Noon) is an EU funded project under the FP7 programme. TERI participated in this competitive bid as one partner in a consortium of institutions led by a European institution and involves several other Indian institutions including IIT Delhi and Kharagpur. Each institute has a well defined role and TERI is addressing the issue of socio-economic impact assessment

 

Q10) What work is TERI doing with Government of Iceland?

 

The Global Centre, Iceland received support from Carnegie Foundation for glacier related work. Our collaboration with this Centre is for the purpose of training and teaching in glaciology.

 

The “billions of dollars” assertion is, of course, an invention, but we see an acknowledgement that TERI is receiving “support” both from the EU and (implied) from the Carnegie Corporation. Here the answer in Q10 is particularly interesting as it claims that the collaboration is “for the purpose of” – i.e., limited to “training and teaching in glaciology.”

 

This makes quite a dramatic contrast with the statements made in a press release, again by TERI, on 15 January 2009 on the Global Centre collaboration, where it states that:

 

Under this collaboration, senior scientists from the respective countries will carry expeditions in the Himalayas. The collaboration, which is its early stage, will be funded primarily by the Carnegie Corporation of New York.

 

The press release goes on to say that:

 

TERI has initiated the establishment of Glacier Monitoring Observatories at Kolahoi Glacier, Jammu and Kashmir and another at East Rathong Glacier, Sikkim. These two glaciers are being monitored with the state-of-art scientific instruments on a regular basis for various parameters like Energy Balance, Mass Balance and Hydrological Balance for the glacierized region.

 

A certain Prof Syed Iqbal Hasnain is also quoted freely in the press release, which records his presence at a meeting between Dr R K Pachauri and Iceland president, Dr Ólafur Grímsson, to celebrate the start of collaboration.

 

Yet, it will be recalled that Hasnain, in his TV debate with me claimed that all the funding for his glaciology work came from TERI and that there was no “outside funding“. He rejected as a “wild allegation” my assertions that funding came from the EU and the Carnegie Corporation.

 

It seems to me that both Hasnain and RK Pachauri need to get their acts together and read their own press releases. At the moment, they are contradicting themselves – this is the blunder that could bring them both down.



Want to share YOUR story with our dynamic and rapidly growing audience?
Click here to become a Contributor.

Not yet rated | UpDown

Comments

Report SPAM
Your report is biased and misleading. It is evident that you have either not done your homework or are just gleefully parroting the warmist apologists. An important and critical information is missing in this reporting. Dr Husnain has since clarified that he had nowhere indicated, let alone mentioned, any year in the interview that was published in New Scientist, picked up by IPCC and now forms the root cause of all the confusion. All that Dr Husnain had indicated was the possibilty of a quickening of meltdown, not ascribing a definite date to it.
Report SPAM
The planet has a natural eco-system to maintain clean healthy foods, clean healthy atmospheres and fresh clean healthy water, yet these basic elements to sustain life on the planet are in jeopardy. Due to human activities: 90% of large ocean sea life is already extinct, 1 in 3 of the world’s population is at risk of the swine flu pandemic, every 5 seconds a child perishes from starvation and methane driven oceanic eruptions threaten life as we know it. Unbiased scientific reports reveal that the leading cause of damage to public health and the natural environment are toxic and non-sustainable industries that support livestock killing for foods, products, research and entertainment. The World Watch Institute states that livestock killing is responsible for 51% or more of harmful greenhouse gases (GHGs) whereas the world’s transportation sector only accounts for 14%. Meat production, killing and consumption are the leading cause of 80% of global warming, 80% of human health problems, 70% use of clean water, 80% deforestation of the Amazon Rain Forest, and the leading cause of water pollution and oceanic dead zones worldwide. The American Dietic Association (ADA) states that plant based nutrition is healthy for all age groups and can even reverse major diseases such as cancers, heart diseases and diabetes. The world’s most highly acclaimed medical experts concur that the human physiology is designed to thrive on edible plant based foods or a vegan life style. Why is the media asking Nobel Peace Laureate Dr. Rajendra Pachauri to resign? Those asked to resign ought to be officials in the USDA, FDA and other positions that keep vital information about the harms of meat, milk/dairy and egg practices from being exposed by the UN, EPA, CDC, WHO and all Peace Keeping Agencies who are in a position to protect the public and the natural environment: the air, land and water. It is not healthy, logical or sustainable to shed blood and create misery just to produce foods and products that ultimately are toxic to people and to the environment. The UN FAO Livestock’s Long Shadow report concurs that livestock is one of the most significant contributors to today’s most serious environmental problems stating that URGENT ACTION is required to remedy the situation. The media needs to fully investigate scientific reports and expose the horrors of animal cruelty and unhygienic animal agriculture practices. Please use your position as media to urge civilized governments especially the world's highest emission producers: the USA/EU, China and India to empower agriculture to quickly adapt to organic plant based resources. Meat, milk/dairy and eggs are toxic and poisonous to children and adults. Cancers, diabetes, heart diseases, obesity and world hunger are at an all time high and global warming trends place all populations worldwide at risk. According to Dr. James Hansen, the world’s leading climate change expert “The single action that a person can take to reduce carbon emissions is vegetarianism.” Arctic Ice Caps melting, Himalayan glaciers and melting of permafrost layers can still be prevented with a global shift that supports using clean wholesome energy solutions that are animal-free, renewable and biodegradable such as organic plants and trees to produce sustainable foods, products and technology. Methane driven oceanic eruptions, place all nations at risk. Please act now and report the truth to protect present and future generations to come. Peace is within reach when killing ceases. Animals are sentient beings not products. Like humans, animals deserve to live free of cruelty, exploitation and killing at the hands of humans. For more information on how to transition to a healthy plant based life style, please visit: The Physician’s Committee for Responsible Medicine www.pcrm.org www.pcrm.org/health/veginfo/vsk The World Peace Diet Book http://worldpeacediet.org/ Help Stop Animal Cruelty www.suprememastertv.com/stop-animal-cruelty http://www.suprememastertv.com/Be-Veg/
Microsoft Google Yahoo! Ask