Read the Beforeitsnews.com story here. Advertise at Before It's News here.
Profile image
By FalkenBlog (Reporter)
Contributor profile | More stories
Story Views
Now:
Last hour:
Last 24 hours:
Total:

Fermi's Intuition on Models

% of readers think this story is Fact. Add your two cents.


In this video snippet, Freeman Dyson talks about an experience he had with Enrico Fermi in 1951. Dyson was originally a mathematician who had just shown how two different formulations of quantum electrodynamics (QED), Feynman diagrams and Schwinger-Tomonoga’s operator method, were equivalent. Fermi was a great experimental and theoretical physicist who built the first nuclear reactor and discovered things like neutrinos, pions, and muons.

Dyson and a team at Cornell were working on a model of strong interactions, the forces that bind protons and neutrons in the nucleus. Their theory had a speculative physical basis: a nucleon field and a pseudo-scalar meson field (the pion field), which interacted with the proton. Their approach was to use the same tricks Dyson used on QED. After a year and a half, they produced a model that generated a nice agreement with Fermi’s empirical work on meson-proton scattering he had produced at his cyclotron in Chicago.

Dyson went to Chicago to explain his theory to Fermi and presented a graph showing how his theoretical calculations matched Fermi’s data. Fermi hardly looked at the graphs, and said,

I’m not very impressed with what you’ve been doing. When one does a theoretical calculation there are two ways of doing it. Either you should have a clear physical model in mind, or you should have a rigorous mathematical basis. You have neither. 

Dyson asked about the numerical agreement between his model and the empirical data. Fermi then responded, ‘how many free parameters did you use for the fitting?’  Dyson noted there were four. Fermi responded, ‘Johnny von Neumann always used to say with four parameters I can fit an elephant, with five I can make him wiggle his trunk. So I don’t find the numerical agreement very impressive.’

I love this because it highlights a good way of looking at models. A handful of free parameters can make any model fit the data, generating the same result as a miracle step in a logical argument.  Either you derive a model from something you know to be true, or you derive them from a theory with a clear intuitive causal mechanism.

The entire interaction took only 15 minutes and was very disappointing, but Dyson was blessed with the wisdom and humility to take Fermi’s dismissal as definitive and went back to Cornell to tell the team they should just write up what they had done and move on to different projects.

While this was crushing, with hindsight Dyson was grateful to Fermi. It saved his team from wasting years on a project that he discovered later would have never worked. There is no ‘pseudo-scalar pion field.’  Eventually, physicists replaced the pion with 2 quarks, of which there are 6, highlighting the futility of the physical basis of their approach. Any experimental agreement they found was illusory.

After this experience, Dyson realized he was best suited to simplify models or connecting axioms to applications like quantum field theory. What was required for the strong interactions at that time was not a deductive solution but an invention–in this case, quarks–and that requires strong intuition. He realized his strengths were more analytic, less intuitive.

Unfortunately, today our best scientists are unconcerned about the ability of free parameters to make a bad theory seem fruitful. In physics, we have inflation, dark matter, and dark energy, things that never been isolated or fit into the Standard Model. In climate science, an anachronistic and clearly wrong Keynesian macro-model is one of many components (e.g., atmospheric, ocean, vegetation). They fit know data well but are totally unfalsifiable.


Source: http://falkenblog.blogspot.com/2020/04/fermis-intuition-on-models.html


Before It’s News® is a community of individuals who report on what’s going on around them, from all around the world.

Anyone can join.
Anyone can contribute.
Anyone can become informed about their world.

"United We Stand" Click Here To Create Your Personal Citizen Journalist Account Today, Be Sure To Invite Your Friends.

Humic & Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex

HerbAnomic’s Humic and Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex is a revolutionary New Humic and Fulvic Acid Complex designed to support your body at the cellular level. Our product has been thoroughly tested by an ISO/IEC Certified Lab for toxins and Heavy metals as well as for trace mineral content. We KNOW we have NO lead, arsenic, mercury, aluminum etc. in our Formula. This Humic & Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral complex has high trace levels of naturally occurring Humic and Fulvic Acids as well as high trace levels of Zinc, Iron, Magnesium, Molybdenum, Potassium and more. There is a wide range of up to 70 trace minerals which occur naturally in our Complex at varying levels. We Choose to list the 8 substances which occur in higher trace levels on our supplement panel. We don’t claim a high number of minerals as other Humic and Fulvic Supplements do and leave you to guess which elements you’ll be getting. Order Your Humic Fulvic for Your Family by Clicking on this Link , or the Banner Below.



Our Formula is an exceptional value compared to other Humic Fulvic Minerals because...


It’s OXYGENATED

It Always Tests at 9.5+ pH

Preservative and Chemical Free

Allergen Free

Comes From a Pure, Unpolluted, Organic Source

Is an Excellent Source for Trace Minerals

Is From Whole, Prehisoric Plant Based Origin Material With Ionic Minerals and Constituents

Highly Conductive/Full of Extra Electrons

Is a Full Spectrum Complex


Our Humic and Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex has Minerals, Amino Acids, Poly Electrolytes, Phytochemicals, Polyphenols, Bioflavonoids and Trace Vitamins included with the Humic and Fulvic Acid. Our Source material is high in these constituents, where other manufacturers use inferior materials.


Try Our Humic and Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex today. Order Yours Today by Following This Link.

Report abuse

    Comments

    Your Comments
    Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green

    MOST RECENT
    Load more ...

    SignUp

    Login

    Newsletter

    Email this story
    Email this story

    If you really want to ban this commenter, please write down the reason:

    If you really want to disable all recommended stories, click on OK button. After that, you will be redirect to your options page.