Drought study raises tricky questions for UN’s climate loss and damage fund

Drought in southern Africa [image credit: BBC News]

” data-image-caption=”" data-medium-file=”https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg?w=300″ data-large-file=”https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg?w=614″ src=”https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg?w=614&h=345″ alt=”" width=”614″ height=”345″ class=”aligncenter size-large wp-image-66954″ srcset=”https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg?w=614 614w, https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg?w=150 150w, https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg?w=300 300w, https://tallbloke.files.wordpress.com/2024/04/drought_sa.jpg 624w” sizes=”(max-width: 614px) 100vw, 614px” />
What defines a ‘climate victim’? The impossible conundrum for the UN, facing claims for any climate-related disaster, is: would/could it have happened (to the same magnitude) anyway, for example due to natural factors or mistakes of some kind, regardless of unproven theories about possible human causes behind weather events? Eligibility for compensation depends on the answer, but funds obviously aren’t unlimited and nobody will readily accept a refusal.
– – –
Since January, swathes of southern Africa have been suffering from a severe drought, which has destroyed crops, spread disease and caused mass hunger.

But its causes have raised tough questions for the new UN fund for climate change losses, says Climate Home News.

Christopher Dabu, a priest in Lusitu parish in southern Zambia, one of the affected regions, said that because of the drought, his parishioners “have nothing”- including their staple food.

“Almost every day, there’s somebody who comes here to knock on this gate asking for mielie meal, [saying] ‘Father, I am dying of hunger’,” Dabu told Climate Home outside his church last month.

The government and some humanitarian agencies were quick to blame the lack of rain on climate change.

Zambia’s green economy minister Collins Nzovu told reporters in March, “there’s a lot of infrastructure damage as a result of climate change”. He added that the new UN-backed loss and damage fund, now being set up to help climate change victims, “must speak to this”.

But last week, scientists from the World Weather Attribution (WWA) group published a study which found that “climate change did not emerge as the significant driver” of the current drought affecting Zambia, Zimbabwe, Malawi, Angola, Mozambique and Botswana.

Instead, they concluded that the El Niño phenomenon – which occurs every few years with warming of sea surface temperatures in the eastern Pacific Ocean – was the drought’s “key driver”. They said the damage was worsened by the vulnerabilities of the countries affected, including reliance on rain-fed farming rather than irrigation.

Nonetheless, briefing journalists on the study, co-authors Joyce Kimutai and Friederike Otto said climate change does make El Niños stronger and more frequent – and therefore could be playing an indirect role in the southern African drought. Otto noted that climate change “might have a small role but not a big one”.

While WWA studies have often found that disasters like this are driven by climate change, there have been other cases where they have played down that link – as with droughts in Brazil in 2014 and Madagascar in 2021, and floods in Italy in 2023.

The complex nature of the science raises a dilemma for those now designing the fledgling loss and damage fund.

Its board holds its first meeting in Abu Dhabi this week. In three days of talks, the board’s 26 members will discuss the fund’s name and how to decide where it will be hosted and who will lead it. Trickier issues like the role of climate change attribution will be left to future meetings.

Climate Home spoke to several experts and two of the fund’s board members, whose opinions were divided on whether the link between climate change and a particular disaster should have to be proven before funds are dished out to affected communities.
. . .
[One commented that] “people facing disasters should not be left behind because of theoretical disputes about attribution”.

Full article here.
– – –
Image: Drought in southern Africa [credit: BBC News]