Ammon Bundy and his co-defendants have been found not guilty of most of the federal conspiracy charges related to their occupation of the wildlife refuge in Oregon. This decision was reached regarding conspiracy to impede federal officers, the possession of firearms in a federal facility, and theft of government vehicle. The jury was unable to reach a verdict about theft of cameras at the facility. The Bundys still face trial in Nevada over a previous 2014 standoff.
As pointed out in an article by The Washington Post, the acquittal on the firearms charge seems strange, though the specific charge was that the defendants possessed guns “with the intent that it ‘be used in the commission of a crime.’” If the jury didn’t regard the other actions as having criminal intent, perhaps that explains this particular decision.
And all of this raises the question of jury nullification. This concept has a long history in our nation, the idea that juries have the power to find a defendant not guilty if they believe the law is unjust or has been unfairly applied. Examples of this in the past have included decisions to ignore the law with regard to the Alien and Sedition Act, the Fugitive Slave Laws, and Prohibition. However, there is also a history of all white juries refusing to convict defendants charged with crimes against blacks. As always when discretion is involved, we’re left to debate the trustworthiness of the people who decide, rather than addressing a principle.
The concept of jury nullification reminds me of the John Adams remark that our Constitution only works when it governs moral people. Though I’ve criticized the Bundys for taking the wrong approach to protest in the past, there is a measure of smugness — dare I say privilege — that I and others need to avoid in telling people with a grievance against our government or some other aspect of society exactly how they will be allowed to express their discontent.
There is another protest going on now that tests our fairness, the resistance to a proposed pipeline across what members of the Standing Rock Sioux regard as tribal land in North Dakota. The objections here are over the specifics of sacred sites and water, but just as with the Bundy protests, all of this gets tied up in the conflicts of the western U.S. that have been going on throughout our history — who owns the land and what is underneath it and flowing over it? How do we square the rights of the people who were here originally with the rights of those of us who came later? And what will we do to balance the needs for using resources now with the need to conserve those same resources into the future and maintain a planet that is inhabitable?
Protest is disruptive. It has to be, since it’s a statement against the settled order. And in a nation that was founded on the idea of people saying no to the leaders of their society, it’s hypocritical for us to seek to shut down all resistance to power. Protest reveals the concerns of people who are often ignored, and while we may have to arrest protestors to remove them from roads, government buildings, and so forth, restraint is the best approach, and the not guilty verdict in the Oregon case is a good example of the jury recognizing that.
The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the position of Guns.com.
The post Bundy, protestors, find acquittals in Oregon wildlife refuge occupation case appeared first on Guns.com.
The Fox News Prostitutes
Insane Bond, Stock, Real Estate Markets - Greg Hunter, Mike Maloney Video
Jason A Blows Your Mind: WTH Is Going On? This Is so Not Normal Yet it's Happening Nationwide! WTH (Mature Video) Jason A Mr Doom
Hold On! State of Emergency, Evacuations: Massive, Massive & Serious Storm Update Three Tornadoes on the Loose (Updated Massive Storm Video)
The Final Word on Alex Jones
Terrifying Warning for Americans
Operation Gotham Shield Update and the "Media Blackout" (Video)
Here's a Very Difficult Video to Watch - But Watch You Must - The Liberal Cancer of America
Serious Combat Readiness: Russia Puts Air Defense on High Alert (Video)
The Relentless Push Towards War: This Time with North Korea. Why?
Why Does Jared Kushner Look Like He Is Getting Ready to Play the Role of the Biblical Antichrist?
Staged ISIS Bombing Video. If This Doesn't Wake You Up, Nothing Will.
Major Leak at Oroville Damn Detected
Russian Military Ship Sinks After Collision
Huge Superstorm Forms Over US. Geoengineering?
Hackers Exploited Word Flaw for Months While Microsoft Investigated
Freemasons Won’t Tell You That They Worship Lucifer As The ‘Light Bearer Of The World’
Pastor Steve Cioccolanti Explains Sheol [Hell] and Seoul from the Israeli Bible
Willie Nelson Halts Concert in Texas – Country Legend was ‘Disoriented’
Israel Bombs Road To Damascus..Airport
'Shocking Footage' of Something You Have to See! (2017-2018) Jason A.
British Police Making Terror Arrests on ‘Near Daily Basis’ as Expert Estimates 10,000 UK Jihadis
Alien (1979) – The Deeper Meaning You Missed – Jay Dyer
U.S. Bumblebee Gets Federal Protection … Finally
The Bullpen Report: Why Cishek Could Be Worth Stashing, Eyeing J. Wilson & More
9 Health Benefits of Walking Barefoot and Connecting With the Earth
EPA and Energy Star Teamed to Ban Real Energy Saving Technology
American Politics Reflects Communist Rivalries
Cop Blocker Arrested for Crossing Street at DUI Checkpoint in Manchester (Video)
The Spiritual Lover of the Inner Silence