Profile image
By Sebastian Clouth
Contributor profile | More stories
Story Views

Last Hour:
Last 24 Hours:

Why Are Rich Chinese Entrepreneurs Leaving China?

Saturday, December 8, 2012 1:57
% of readers think this story is Fact. Add your two cents.


Chinese entrepreneurs are leaving China. According  a survey, conducted by China Merchants Bank and Bain & Co., 27% of entrepreneurs worth over 100 million RMB have already emigrated and 47% of them are considering moving abroad.

The growing trend is nurturing resentment towards wealthy emigrants among Chinese citizens. And the recent exposure of a prominent businesswoman and member of the CPPCC (China’s political advisory body) Zhang Lan’s immigration further triggered controversy in Chinese society.

Economic insecurity

Chinese Entrepreneur Magazine [zh] analyzed:

Zhang Lan’s emigration triggered controversy in Chinese society. Screen capture from local news-report via Youku.


Chinese entrepreneurs all suffer from a lack of security. Once they emigrate to another economic system, they will be provided with new opportunities independent of the Chinese economy. The diversity lowers their risk compared to doing business only in one country(China) where policies can be unstable. Overall, it helps to enhance their sense of security.[zh], a prominent Chinese newspaper, shared similar opinion:


Honestly, Chinese society doesn’t provide citizens with a sense of security. Average citizens may think rich people feel safe because they don’t need to worry about social welfare; however, rich people in China feel even less safe. Recently, one of China’s richest men Liang Wengen said his property and life belong to the country and that the Party members’ wives are more beautiful. It seems a stupid thing to say, but it reveals his fear. How can an entrepreneur make such a statement about his property? Any entrepreneur knows clear property rights are essential for doing business.

Rigid Rules for Chinese Enterprises 

Huang Song[zh], Secretary-General of Finance Industry and Development Research Center of Peking University pointed out a neglected reason behind the immigration:


There are many reasons why entrepreneurs choose to emigrate. Public opinion is usually concerned with two reasons: first, they do not have confidence in China’s future; second, they are trying to escape from something illegal they have done. But there’s a very important reason often ignored, that is, the large number of government restrictions and barriers to overseas investment and financing. First, due to the control of foreign exchange under the capital account, overseas investment by Chinese enterprises need to be approved by the Foreign Exchange Management Department. And although the investment polices have become more relaxed than the past, there are still a lot of limitations and financial investment is still strictly managed. Second, overseas investment has to be approved by the Development and Reform Department, which brings a lot of uncertainty to projects.

China’s financial system essentially only supports state-owned enterprises and large enterprises. For private enterprises and small and medium-sized enterprises there exist difficulties in financing: it’s difficult to get loans, and even more difficult to go public or issue bonds.

Yang Yongmin[zh], GM of Offshore Incorporations Group Beijing Office echoed:

晒歪歪:不出所料,俏江南张兰移民到了那个加勒比海的一个岛国。了解这个情况的都知道,这跟张兰是否爱国没任何关系,纯粹是资本项下的移民,为公司海外上市考虑。 中国总有很多傻比的政策,坑了自己人,肥了外国人。

I’m not surprised that Zhang Lan emigrated to that Caribbean island. People who have a little knowledge about Chinese private companies know that it has nothing to do with whether Zhang loves the country or not. It’s because it’s easier for the company to go public overseas. There are so many stupid policies in China that inconvenience Chinese themselves and benefit foreign countries.

People’s Daily published a commentary suggesting following the Americans by implementing heavier taxes on rich entrepreneurs to prevent them from emigrating, the piece soon triggered netizens’ disagreement. Famous TV show host Meng Fei criticized:

孟非: 这个思路有问题!你见过几个美国富豪放弃美国国籍?应该思考的为什么那么多官员家眷、演艺明星、大小富豪、著名学者都想移民?而不是琢磨怎么给他们移民设置更高的门槛。不反省这个问题,设置再高的门槛也留不住。

This thinking is in the wrong direction. How many rich Americans choose to give up their nationality? What we need to consider is why so many officials, celebrities, rich people and famous scholars want to emigrate, not how to prevent them from doing so. If we don’t reflect on this problem, we can never keep them no matter how strict the rules might be.

Zhi Qiangli echoed:


Zhang Lan’s emigration is a slap in the face to the rigid system.

Also, there are a lot of rules and policies that make it difficult for Chinese private companies to go public but foreign enterprises are exempt from these policies. Perhaps chief editor of Workers’ Daily Shi shusi’s words best summarized the problems China needs to tackle in the next decade:


The controversy continues, patriotism aside; the result is a black comedy. As the boss of a private company, she couldn’t make her companies go public in China due to strict rules and difficulties with financing [esp. for restaurant chain business]; however, now that she has emigrated, she stands a better chance of taking her company public. Of course, the outcome is not perfect for China, but who’s responsible for this? The huge emigration trend is just a sign of China’s economic problems. Instead of blaming entrepreneurs, why don’t we promote the formation of consensus for reform and call for more respect for personal property rights, the rule of law and establishment of a just market environment in China?

Creative Commons License

Written by Abby 

Republished from Global Voices Online

We encourage you to Share our Reports, Analyses, Breaking News and Videos. Simply Click your Favorite Social Media Button and Share.

Report abuse


Your Comments
Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green

Total 3 comments
  • newvisionhotel

    The construction of Hanoi Newvision Hotel is since 2008 and it welcomes the first guest in October 2010, just on the celebration of Hanoi millennium festival. Managed under the Hanoi Emotion Jsc, including a team of 28 professional staff, most of them with many years experience in the hospitalities industry, we guarantee to all guests and partner a satisfaction of services.
    Quietly & comfortably, Hotel in Hanoi Newvision Hotel is a new and modern three stars hotel in Hanoi located in the central. It only takes you few minutes by walking to Temple of Literature, Ho Chi Minh Mausoleum, One Pillar Pagoda… . The hotel is located in one of 36 old streets of Hanoi Old Quarter.
    The Hotel offers a very QUIET environment for perfect relaxing even it’s located at the center of bustling Hanoi. This feature is the plus point as a business hotel in Hanoi for business man.
    Hotel in Hanoi Newvision is designed in warm decoration, a harmony of modern comfort and the Hanoi’s traditional charm.
    Hotel in Hanoi Newvision all rooms are with OPEN WINDOWS, and equipped with the comfortable mattress, wooden floor, nice bathtub or standing bath, LCD 32 inches screen … Moreover, all rooms have its own SAFETY BOX and FREE WIFI inside which is always available. The special thing is that we have a modern generator with strong capacity to make sure the POWER is ALWAYS availability not only inside all rooms but also the elevator and the hall.
    We deeply understand that not only the modern amenities but the service and the customer’s belief are the key to our growing path.
    Managed by a professional team with more than 15 years in hospitality industry,Hotel in Hanoi Newvision Hotel will be more than your expectation!
    NewVisionHotel. All rights reserved.
    Add: 68c-70 Hang Bo Str – Hoan Kiem Dist – Ha Noi.
    Tel: 84 4 3923 4132 – Fax: 84 4 3923 4133 .
    Hotline: 84 9 0427 3734 – Email:

  • Anonymous

    The affluent will propel 40% of China’s consumption growth and will comprise 35% of all consumer spending in 2020, up from 24% last year, according to BCG. Their spending will grow fivefold to $3.1 trillion in the next eight years. The upper affluent — those earning between $40,000 and $1 million per year — will account for 40% of the 280 million!

  • Pateriot

    This will backfire on the rich Chinese that immigrate to the US. By the time that Obama and the Left are done with this country we ALL may be wanting to immigrate to China!!

Top Stories
Recent Stories



Top Global


Top Alternative




Email this story
Email this story

If you really want to ban this commenter, please write down the reason:

If you really want to disable all recommended stories, click on OK button. After that, you will be redirect to your options page.