Carbon Dioxide Capture May Be Solved

Sandia National Laboratories and University of New Mexico researchers have designed a series of nanoscopic membranes made of water saturated by an enzyme that empties coal smoke of CO2 more cheaply and efficiently than any known technology. The enzyme the team found to make the biologically inspired membrane is one naturally developed over millions of years to clear CO2.

The patented work, the paper of which has been published in Nature Communications, has interested power and energy companies that would like to significantly and inexpensively reduce emissions of carbon dioxide, one of the most widespread “greenhouse gases”, and explore other possible uses of the invention.

Researchers term the membrane a “memzyme” because it acts like a filter but is near-saturated with an enzyme, carbonic anhydrase, developed by living cells over millions of years to help rid themselves of carbon dioxide efficiently and rapidly.

The new memzyme meets the Department of Energy’s standards by capturing 90 percent of power plant carbon dioxide production at a relatively low cost of $40 per ton.

Jeff Brinker, a Sandia fellow, University of New Mexico regents’ professor and the paper’s lead author said, “To date, stripping carbon dioxide from smoke has been prohibitively expensive using the thick, solid, polymer membranes currently available. Our inexpensive method follows nature’s lead in our use of a water-based membrane only 18 nanometers thick that incorporates natural enzymes to capture 90 percent of carbon dioxide released. (A nanometer is about 1/700 of the diameter of a human hair.) This is almost 70 percent better than current commercial methods, and it’s done at a fraction of the cost.”

Coal power plants are one of the United States’ largest energy producers, but they have been criticized by some for sending more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere than any other form of electrical power generation. Still, coal burning in China, India and other countries means that U.S. abstinence alone is not likely to solve the world’s climate problems. But, Brinker said, “maybe technology will.”

The memzyme’s formation begins with a drying process called evaporation-induced self-assembly, first developed at Sandia by Brinker 20 years ago and a field of study in its own right.

The procedure creates a close-packed array of silica nanopores designed to accommodate the carbonic anhydrase enzyme and keep it stable. This is done in several steps. First, the array, which may be 100 nanometers long, is treated with a technique called atomic layer deposition to make the nanopore surface water-averse or hydrophobic. This is followed by an oxygen plasma treatment that overlays the water-averse surface to make the nanopores water-loving or hydrophilic, but only to a depth of 18 nanometers. A solution of the enzyme and water spontaneously fill up and are stabilized within the water-loving portion of the nanopores. This creates membranes of water 18 nanometers thick, with a carbonic anhydrase concentration 10 times greater than aqueous solutions made to date.

The solution, at home in its water-loving sleeve, is stable. But because of the enzyme’s ability to rapidly and selectively dissolve carbon dioxide, the catalytic membrane has the capability to capture the overwhelming majority of carbon dioxide molecules that brush up against it from a rising cloud of coal smoke. The hooked molecules then pass rapidly through the membranes, driven solely by a naturally occurring pressure gradient caused by the large number of carbon dioxide molecules on one side of the membrane and their comparative absence on the other.

The chemical process turns the gas briefly into carbonic acid and then bicarbonate before exiting immediately downstream as carbon dioxide gas. The gas can be harvested with 99 percent purity – so pure that it could be used by oil companies for resource extraction. Other molecules pass by the membrane’s surface undisturbed. The enzyme is reusable, and because the water serves as a medium rather than an actor, does not need replacement.

Except the nanopores dry out over long periods of time due to evaporation. But this will be compensated by water vapor rising from lower water baths already installed in power plants to reduce sulfur emissions. And, enzymes damaged from use over time can easily be replaced.

Brinker noted, “The very high concentration of carbonic anhydrase, along with the thinness of the water channel, result in very high carbon dioxide flux through the membrane. The greater the carbonic anhydrase concentration, the greater the flux. The thinner the membrane, the greater the flux.”

The membrane’s arrangement in a generating station’s flue would be like that of a catalytic converter in a car, suggested Brinker. The membranes would sit on the inner surface of a tube arranged like a honeycomb. The flue gas would flow through the membrane-embedded tube, with a carbon dioxide-free gas stream on the outside of the tubes. Varying the tube length and diameter would optimize the carbon dioxide extraction process.

Susan Rempe, Sandia researcher and co-author, is who suggested and developed the idea of inserting carbonic anhydrase into the water solution to improve the speed by which carbon dioxide could be taken up and released from the membrane. She said, “The enzyme can catalyze the dissolution of a million carbon dioxide molecules per second, vastly improving the speed of the process. With optimization by industry, the memzyme could make electricity production cheap and green.”

The press release suggested the separation process could increase the amount of fuel obtained during enhanced oil recovery using carbon dioxide injected into existing reservoirs. There are many other uses possible.

Rempe also noted a slightly different enzyme, used in the same process, can convert methane – an even more potent greenhouse gas – to the more soluble methanol for removal.

University of New Mexico professor and paper co-author Ying-Bing Jiang, is who originated and developed the idea of using watery membranes based on the human body’s processes to separate out carbon dioxide. He noted prior cleansing by industrial scrubbers means that the rising smoke will be clean enough not to significantly impair membrane efficiency and that the membranes have operated efficiently in laboratory settings for months.

The press release also noted that the technology could also sequester carbon dioxide on a spacecraft, the authors mention, because the membranes operate at ambient temperatures and are driven solely by chemical gradients.

This is a technological breakthrough and if it scales up to industrial proportions could very well revolutionize the basic energy structure of the world’s economy. A gallon or about 6.3 pounds of gasoline at this writing is worth at wholesale $2.07/6.3 = $.3236 per pound or an imperial ton is worth $647.14. That leaves about $600 to work the CO2 back into a fuel.

Something is bound to happen with this. CO2 to CO is progressing, too, and that springs lots more opportunities. Might want one of these for my car someday, after all a gallon of gas yields about 20 pounds of CO2.

If this works out these folks are scientific heroes.