Profile image
By Deborah Dupre (Reporter)
Contributor profile | More stories
Story Views

Now:
Last Hour:
Last 24 Hours:
Total:

Most Damning MH370 Criminal Evidence: Audio Recording Crisis Actors Not In Plane (Video)

Friday, May 2, 2014 21:16
% of readers think this story is Fact. Add your two cents.

(Before It's News)

 

 

The Malaysian government finally released a recording, supposedly of the conversation between Malaysian Flight 370 and Air Traffic Control, but a forensic expert shows in detail that it is a bogus audio recording in a video (below).

 

“Why did the Malaysian government do this?” is the question needing an answer, for the sake of 239 missing persons, through an independent international investigation that is United Nations’sanctioned. 

 

[See: Highly Suspicious MH370 Audio Recording Played For Families]

 

“I had the opportunity to listen to the recording and have several concerns from an audio forensic perspective,” says audio-visual forensic expert Ed Primeau of Primeau Forensics.

 

The scientist and Brasscheck concur with what Before It’s News reader Wiseman has said: 

 

The audio is neither from the cockpit nor the pilots cabin.

 

“It’s very strange,” Primeau says.

 

“At approximately 1:14… it sounds like someone is holding a digital recorder up to a speaker, so it’s a microphone-to-speaker transfer of that information. That’s a pretty big deal because it raises the first red flag about there possibly being some editing.”

 

“There is no question that the recording of the air control communications of Flight 370 released today was tampered with,” reports Brasscheck TV. “What they released was clearly altered. Some material came from a different source. Other material is flat out missing. Bizarre.

 

“Did they think we would not notice? What on earth made them think they could get away with this?”

 

Read: Highly Suspicious MH370 Audio Recording Played For Families

 

Sources: Brasscheck TV, YouTube

Report abuse

Comments

Your Comments
Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green

Total 50 comments
  • Deborah Dupre

    Crisis actors again. Big business these days, eh?
    Thank you once again Mr. Wiseman.
    Why would the Malaysia government do this? It’s a shabby job, indeed.

    • AgainstEVILZionist-MASTERMIND-of-IlluminatiNWO

      Jeez, you keep blasting the Malaysian Govt don’t you?!

      • Deborah Dupre

        Jeez – you keep spamming with the same comment pasted under my articles. Spamming is not allowed, my friend.

      • apache5

        I see we have a new TRoll on-board, probably same person just changed his or her handle. cannot wait for the TAKING back of our country and we can try all these scumbags and send em to jail or hell which the court decides!!!
        :twisted:

    • AINT HAVE A BIRTH CERTIFICATE - FOOLD YA\'ALL

      …and why did the CIA visit with the airline just after Obama left his international visit to Malay?
      All rigged, cheated, deceived but one day these idiots will answer! America is corrupt!

    • Mind Scribble

      Hi,
      I have just signed up simply to reply to this post. I have enjoyed reading your other articles and find what you have to say fascinating, however in this case, is it not likely that the video you use to demonstrate actors due to the “edits” mentioned are not edits in the sense of trying to hide something but merely in the sense that they have been condensed into a smaller timeframe so as to not have minutes upon minutes of silence. A simple copying and pasting method in audio software to make a track smaller would account for the lack of noise. Unless I am mistaken they haven’t released this recording in real time but condensed all the communications from however longer the flight made them into a convenient time scale for the public to hear them.

      Furthermore the recordings are obviously made at ATC so one can presume it records all other air traffic communication too, seeing as though they will be dealing with more than just one flight, this naturally would have to be cut out of the recordings too.

      I agree completely with what you have to say about it being a shabby job however I think if you factor in the reasons mentioned above it gives a balanced counter argument to the audio specialists claims.

      As I said I do enjoy your articles and look forward to reading more.

      • Deborah Dupre

        Thank you very much, Mr. Junk. It seems your analysis on the “edits” differ to that of the forensic expert. I don’t quite get and wonder why he found it so obvious, but not you.

        I’d much appreciate it if you could please explain what makes it clear to you the recordings were obviously made at ATC – and not in a studio.

        Even if this is condense, who is speaking? Officials repeatedly said at first it was not the pilot. Then, they said it’d not the co-pilot.

        Thank you once again.

      • Arlene Johnson

        Hello Mind Junk-To understand that the various governments are lying to us, please read these links:

        http://owg.livejournal.com/2014/03/16/
        http://owg.livejournal.com/2014/03/17/
        http://owg.livejournal.com/2014/03/31/
        http://owg.livejournal.com/2014/04/02/

      • Mind Scribble

        Thanks for your reply.

        I’m not saying for certain whether or not the recordings are by actors, or done in a studio, when I used the word obviously I was suggesting that if at face value we are to believe there is no coverup then the recordings had to be recorded at the ATC side, this would account for the edits so frequently mentioned in the experts analysis.

        My comment wasn’t written to discredit your work or opinion but merely to see what you or anyone else thought about my theory at least to do with the experts opinion on the edits, or parts with lack of noise. I feel it’s plausible. As for why I found it not as obvious as the forensic expert; the released recordings (if considered real) run at a time frame much shorter than that of the reported length of the flight before last contact., this is what led me to the conclusion that there should of course be sections cut out producing no noise, because they have condensed the recording for public audience.

        I am only commenting on one aspects of his analysis, the other factors such as change in voice tone and audio quality are two areas I support you in the inconsistencies, although I’suggest (but don’t assert) a transmission with engine noise in the background as opposed to the early transmissions on the ground may account for some audio quality issues. But that doesn’t explain the change back to higher quality audio later in the recording.

        As for who’s speaking I’m not sure and I fully accept the possibility it could be a coverup or actors, that’s why I read your post.

        Arlene, I accept that all that you linked to is possible, a complete lack of discovery of wreckage in areas they’ve spent millions searching also leads me to believe something is not quite right.

        I have a legal background, I am no expert in any of the areas I will comment on, but I am about looking at evidence and opinion and attempting to interpret it myself. If we can analyse any given evidence and offer alternate explanations for some aspects but not others then those other aspects are the ones which lend most support to an argument of something being covered up, or at least not in line with any official story or statement.

        Hopefully I’ve responded to what you have asked.

        Thanks for your time

  • jimmythehat

    very good vid. ty

  • Marilynn Reeves

    This plane will NEVER be found because it was never LOST.

    • Betty

      that is what I have been saying all along.

    • Rip

      Oh come on! Go back to reading ALICE IN WONDERLAND. Jump in the rabbit hole and see what you find.

    • John

      that’s quite a good possibility Marilyn…the whole thing could have been staged

      • Deborah Dupre

        Mike – If you carefully review my articles about the 2 planes involved, one can see how the whole thing could have been staged. The other Boeing could have been brought back specifically for the staging. In fact – that’s what it looks like. This is why even if the MRO Boeing is found, it’s unlikely the passengers would be found with it. They would have been either: 1) ordered off of it before it crashed, or more likely in my opinion, never were on it in the first place, but instead, boarded the MRQ. That plane’s combined intellectual property value was far too valuable to destroy it. It was valued at “many many billions of dollars.”

    • Deborah Dupre

      Agreed. I’ve even written an article to that effect. It was not lost. It did not “disappear.” Seems mainstream have forgotten – or more likely were instructed to drop the words “hijacking” and “criminal investigation.”

      It was hijacked. There are still, however, 239 “missing persons.”

  • Rip

    I do professional recording and agree that this is professionally done by actors. This recording was done in a professional studio. Great job actors!!! A recording from an airplane would sound rough and contain a hissing sound. This sounds like it may have been edited too. There are no “outside” sounds on this recording. Sorry mainstream news media. I don’t buy it! Try again!

  • Wretched Infidel

    This was all weird from the beginning. It may be the Devil’s Triangle sucked them thru the vortex of death,

    or the fight between the pilot and the co-pilot over becoming a Paradise Islam Island slave-owner of 72 boys and girls with no say and no rights, regardless of the atheists’ attempts to dissuade him (struggling to keep the plane aloft, zig-zagging and roller-coastering all up and down in the sky, “No, NO! Like I told you before, the Imams lie to you there is NO SUCH PLACE, don’t do this!”…)

    or they landed in Saudi Arabia off the peninsula on an island or somewhere in Pakistan like in a Bin Ladin-type hideout until the others are ready…

    JUST don’t even wonder any more about this, they suck all your energy away by placing this on the news still, it is a psyop any way that you want to look at it now, a distraction, from Benghazi, (its the other way round, Nancy Pelosi, the other way around you lying biT–)

    so just do not care any more… they cannot use your energy that way.
    Tell them to go to hell with their ‘news’ of the ‘missing Malaysian plane’.

    Sorry for the families who are not Muslim; the lesson you can take from this is.. never have anything to do with any country like Malaysia which is Muslim-run or has a significant Muslim population; never go on their public transportation, trains, planes and automobiles (taxis) which are run by a large percentage of Islamic Jihadis are INHERENTLY UNSAFE for INFIDELS. (CHINESE, AMERICAN, EUROPEAN, AFRICAN OR ASIAN!)

    BOYCOTT THOSE SERVICES AND THOSE COUNTRIES.

    • Deborah Dupre

      Islamophobia is unacceptable. Aside from that, however, can you name which religion has killed more people than any other? Hint: Is is not Islam.

  • Wretched Infidel

    oH yeah,

    I forgot SHIPS AND FERRIES….

  • Wretched Infidel

    In the case of ships and ferries, you might try to remember that any Satanist-controlled (service or entity such as transportation, companies, countries) are unsafe for others – not just the Islamic Satanist controlled ones.

  • Wretched Infidel

    The more sophisticated ones (Western Satanists) just happen to like to USE the less-able, less-educated less intelligent Islamic Satanists for their destructive capabilities. For now.

  • Daveyo

    Hi Deb

    Just heard this tape. Not sure if its the original or not, as you know many can play games with tapes OK.

    However I can confirm the very beginning is genuine on that video, but afterwards, no its not genuine. Don’t forget I have listened to ATC and Pilots transmitting for 40 years.

    The changes are obvious indeed. As I said before just reading the transcript I already knew it was NOT NORMAL ATC TO PILOT TRANSMISSIONS. All pilots have to do the readback on their instructions because its a mandatory rule by the FAA unless the airport is under MONITOR. Many of you do not know about this part. This announcement from ATC means no pilot is to converse with ATC and its considered a airport emergency or in other words a lockdown is in effect. Similar to what happened after 9/11. All aircraft is to go as directed by ATC without any change or request.

    I gave two articles to BIN Debbie, and its my first time ever on two other subjects, and was wondering if you can review and perhaps post it. I titled one under events which was about the Islamic crucifixions, the the other under Religion about certain parts of the Bible that somehow I connected together that seems rather peculiar, which raises up a very serious question.

    Therefore I can confirm that the audio if it is the original genuine one its been tampered with and altered. I know these transmissions in the back of my heart and head after listening to it for 40 years.

    take care Debbie and keep up the good work.

  • Puffin

    The Malaysian Gov. traded the plane in exchange for high tech weaponry/drone. This is what was used to kill Karpal Singh of the Opposition party. Look at his car wreckage photos and see how they completely nuked the entire side he was sitting at. No clear damage to front, back or the other side of the car. A most unusual car wreck. Mathias Chang lied about government involvement. He should know better!

  • Who dat

    Total bs from start to finish from all the parties involved. Who do they get to produce and direct these false flags, I could do at least twice as good a job, their stories always have more holes than the Dallas cowboys cheerleaders.?

  • Anonymous

    Why can’t the government instigators of all this rubbish do these things properly they have all the facilities at their disposal microphone against loudspeaker, I stopped doing that 50 years ago when at school. Why not direct recording, and seamless edit with constant levels and background noise from another flight. I could do better on a home computer. Could it be they wanted somebody to expose as a fake or the person doing recording knew what really happened and wanted to get caught to expose it. You can’t pull this stuff off since 911 and all the technical equipment and public expertise available today.

    • John

      ok so what are you saying….this recording is faked by the reporter? or the Malaysian government?
      I understand about the tech available to the public and am aware or sound editing programs to do better jobs than what is heard here I am just not sure as to what you are implying is all

  • Anonymous

    I still say MH370 was hijacked and flown to Diego Garcia. Just too many things pointing in that direction including this attempted cover up. Where it went after that I don’t know, they may have flown it out somewhere and crashed it as part of the cover up.

    If this was a black ops job, it’s entirely plausible that another plane could have accompanied MH370 and jammed radar and communications between it and ground controllers to make it “disappear”. And it’s entirely possible the continuing search for wreckage is part of the cover up.

    • Daveyo

      Its a strong possibility, because I thought in the very beginning that it was where it went when it was reported.

      The problem is > This is a super top secret Naval and Air Force Base, and it holds missiles that have multiple Thermonuclear warheads in the near 100 megaton range. Besides that there is more to say on it, but because of its status quo, the public are not even allowed near that base without top security clearance. Its very well defended. Has the B-52′s, the B-2 bombers there, has the F-117 stealths there, and several other planes that will spook you literally. It can also service the aircraft carriers and submarines as well. They even hold prisoners that are considered so called terrorists. It will not surprise me to think or find out later that Osama Bin Laden is still alive and held at that base. Anyone want to make a bet on that aspect???

      Take care.

  • endogro

    Here’s a little more information. http://goo.gl/kmQiQb

  • NoMAD

    Stop this nonsense. This is how ATC (Air Traffic Controller) audio feed sound anywhere on this planet. There is not one non-stop comunication via airplane and ATC. Its not like you are tunign to your radio and always hear a background noise. C’mon!!!
    Pick a feed from one airport and listen ;) http://www.liveatc.net/archive.php

  • worldwatchers

    That plane is so important in completing the very few real disasters that need to be completed to usher in the End Times. They are here now but until they force even the fools to see..The fools will not believe . I should not call the people fools for they are the one blinded by God just as he did in Ancient Egypt. That is when the Jew became his people and as such have been hunted for sport. Hunted for hate! Hunted for they truly are the Chosen ! That is why the Islamics must destroy every Jew they can find! It is as old as time. How dare the Jew be chosen by the Lord God Almighty instead of the Muslim. Maybe cuttng off heads other people of God Like the Christian for Jesus Christ has Chose them! Do the Muslim real think God Almighty would want to see children raped or worse if there ever was as worse. The Muslim can and does commit the very worst torture known to Man as only the Islamics can be so brutal !! All other Muslims can do no more then close their Eyes and try not to hear or see what they know they must Allow!!
    That has been taken over it is so important to follow the rules of the masses but unfourtunity they have no rules.
    And to the ones who with light can look in the eyes of the chaos people the leaders of America look in their eyes as the talk only Hate and Disgust live in the Liberal mind!!

    Storage of water would be good protect your selves as best you can no good times ahead!

  • rankingdread

    Authorities arrested and interrogated 11 Al-Qaeda-linked terrorists in connection with the disappearance of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 last week. The suspects were also further arrested in Malaysia’s capital Kuala Lumpur and in the state of Kedah.

    http://rt.com/news/line/2014-05-04/#60636

  • Anonymous

    Sacred Gematri: MH370 370MH 3L0HM ELOHM ELOHIM H.I.M. His Imperial Majesty Soon Come!
    #MH370-#Ukraine #UFO: #Nephalim AbductionTreaty ReqStagedEvent,
    aka #MSM FakeNews http://youtu.be/UxjziKU4K1c
    http://youtu.be/kgDBsFSdQes
    #ConnectingDots Vanishing #Malaysia #MH370-199′ 11″…#Ukraine #UFO #DreadKnot Anunnaki LightBeing ROD http://youtu.be/oQNHIOjZSeo

  • Hegelian

    I love this….. The Powers that be can not make a department to match the general public. Out of the Blue a Gentleman comes along and does a forensic study of the tape. For free. Nice job. The government would have to find an EXPERT and then convince him that what he is hearing he is not hearing. It makes sense to me “the argument’ . Everyone knows what a snow job it is. The heads of governments around the world are standing around with the same look you get from a teenage who has been caught playing with themselves.

  • Anonymous

    There is more information here see http://www.thereligionofpeace.com

  • dido2

    Deborah, good article. I appreciate your stories, one of several contributors whom I feel I can trust.
    Gracias, Chuy.

    • Deborah Dupre

      Dido2, thank you very much.

  • cryptkeeper

    The PTB have now invented a previously unheard of terrorist organization to blame for the MH370 mystery.Do you really believe that a terrorist organization would have kept quiet this long about such a sinister achievement?Any real terrorists would have been shouting from the rooftops long before now.This disappearance and subsequent cover up could only be accomplished by a major world power with unlimited resources at their disposal.I personally dont believe this new terrorist group exists.This is no more than a fabrication leaked by the government and you can guess which government if you like,to start another wild goose chase.

  • Real Deal

    Thinking that questioning the authenticity of Malaysian Airlines editing in an article displaying a highly edited picture of a Malaysian Airlines jet with smoke pouring out of it really doesn’t support our case for accurate presentation of the facts. Just a thought.

  • Deborah Dupre

    Why do you keep copying an dpasting your same comment pushing Jim Stone under all my articles? This is called spamming and is intolerable.

  • AgainstEVILZionist-MASTERMIND-of-IlluminatiNWO

    What’s your problem with Jim Stone? So you are able to to dominate the news on MH370 here, whilst blassting Jim Stone (and starngely Jim Stone’s articles don#t last long on BIN here) and the Malaysian Govt; and my comment is ‘spam’?! Such PATHETIC juvenile behaviour – so your freedom of speech with crappy spam news are ok whilst you try to shut up anyone who doesn’t agree with your theory?!! Who do you really work for?!

  • AgainstEVILZionist-MASTERMIND-of-IlluminatiNWO

    Oh I forgot, you even copy and paste about the degrading ‘psychological’ reason of Jim Stone using capital letters – what the heck!

  • Veritas

    Your intolerable Deborah or Apache5.

    Your articles suck.

    Quit posting altogether, get a life and real job.

    Oh, Apache5 posts the same stupid comment about trolls and taking back our country…

    blah – blah -blah.

    Hey Apache5?

    Come and take it!

  • DK

    I can understand it in that he uses other peoples work without reference as his own, and always leaves some logical flaw in his articles to undermine his arguement.

    He is mostly right, but imperfect and for a claimed ex NSA man, claims to be computer illiterate. In which case you seek out the relevant expertise elsewhere to double check, secure your information sources – essential in the wired world and give credit where credit is due.

    You would have noticed this in searching for Fukushima and flight CH 370 in that the data on the security company, the reasoning behind its actions and what it had done were all in identical articles to Jim Stones 4 days after the earthquake, including the diagrams which were collated into his article, also 4Chans discussion ran on its boards for at least 7 days about Phillip Wood and Jim Stone only found the edited 4plebs archive which was a fake page – the original threads ran for several days before delection, what you could see in its ‘archive’ of 4Chan was a cut and paste edit of what was on the screen for 2 hours of thread.

    The binary data on the edited photograph which you accessed by clicking the identically sized image (which had all data stripped out) had been edited by Photoshop and Picasa( an iphone gallery tool – not unusual). Photoshop means the photo has been edited by a computer therefore not genuine.

    Journalism is not reporting things, it is finding them out for yourself and investigating the truth. The truth here is found in the incremental backups of 4chans cloud host near Bern Switzerland the location of which I discovered with iplookup, to find the truth he should have contacted the Host, asked them for the original page which under Swiss law they keep in archive for 10 years in case of child porn or illegal activity. 4Chan has not been at all helpful, which should tell you everything about the truth according to 4Chan. It moved its cloud host to Mexico. Going this extra mile, contacting 4Chan and its web host, getting the original web page and making sure is part of the job.

    Jim Stone is very good at collating the big picture from other peoples work, but by that same measure not good enough with his own efforts which is the difference between a graduate and a Master and professionals notice the difference, we have some regulars on this site.

  • Daveyo

    What are the actual qualifications of Jim Stone.

    First copying and pasting articles made from others is called Plagiarism!!!!!

    Plagiarism is theft of another person’s writings or ideas. Generally, it occurs when someone steals expressions from another author’s composition and makes them appear to be his own work. Plagiarism is not a legal term; however, it is often used in lawsuits. Courts recognize acts of plagiarism as violations of Copyright law, specifically as the theft of another person’s Intellectual Property. Because copyright law allows a variety of creative works to be registered as the property of their owners, lawsuits alleging plagiarism can be based on the appropriation of any form of writing, music, and visual images.

    If such article is meant for investigative purposes one should specify the origins of the article and give credit to that persons article and announce that you are investigating such article and verifying the truth or false of such article.

    If Mr. Stone does this part for investigative purposes on others articles, he must make such statement and credit the original article >to the original author and then can make his own opinions and comments or investigative statements to such article without violating copyright laws.

    No one who makes an article should be subjected to being shoved under Mr. Jim Stone. That to me is not being very professional and downright becoming a nuisance which in effect can lead to an argument and possible lawsuit. Heed to my warning and to my advice OK.

    Peace to all.

  • apache5

    Veritas,
    Thank You for replying, now we have you, and yes we are coming !!
    see you soon!!!
    :twisted:

  • John

    well one would think it was common courtesy to give credit where credit is due, but we live in a time of “numbers” and “likes” and how much you attract advertising blah blah blah so I guess common courtesy is not a trait amongst some reporters now…

Top Stories
Recent Stories
 

Featured

 

Top Global

 

Top Alternative

 

Register

Newsletter

Email this story
Email this story

If you really want to ban this commenter, please write down the reason:

If you really want to disable all recommended stories, click on OK button. After that, you will be redirect to your options page.