Profile image
By Reason Magazine (Reporter)
Contributor profile | More stories
Story Views

Last Hour:
Last 24 Hours:

Under Florida’s ‘Stand Your Ground’ Law, Black and White Defendants Fare Equally Well

Friday, July 19, 2013 9:57
% of readers think this story is Fact. Add your two cents.

In my column last week, I noted two complementary narratives that cloud people’s understanding of the George Zimmerman case: one about race, the other about the alleged defects of Florida’s self-defense law. Last year the Tampa Bay Times tried to get a sense of how these two factors interact by looking at racial patterns in self-defense cases. Its findings belie the idea that the enforcement of Florida’s law is biased against black defendants:

The Times analysis found no obvious bias in how black defendants have been treated:

• Whites who invoked the law were charged at the same rate as blacks.

• Whites who went to trial were convicted at the same rate as blacks.

• In mixed-race cases involving fatalities, the outcomes were similar. Four of the five blacks who killed a white went free; five of the six whites who killed a black went free.

• Overall, black defendants went free 66 percent of the time in fatal cases compared to 61 percent for white defendants—a difference explained, in part, by the fact blacks were more likely to kill another black.

That last point relates to a finding that could be seen as evidence of racial bias: While black and white defendants fared equally well, people who killed blacks were more likely to make successful self-defense claims than people who killed whites. “People who killed a black person walked free 73 percent of the time,” the Times reported, “while those who killed a white person went free 59 percent of the time.” The Times conceded that its analysis “does not prove that race caused the disparity between cases with black and white victims,” since “other factors may be at play.” For example, “black victims were more likely to be carrying a weapon when they were killed” and “more likely than whites to be committing a crime, such as burglary, at the time.”

Critics of Florida’s law may seize upon the numbers regarding victims and cite Zimmerman’s acquittal as another example of how the criminal justice system values black people’s lives less than white people’s. But they will find no support in the numbers regarding defendants for the often heard claim that Trayvon Martin would have been arrested immediately and ultimately convicted if he had shot Zimmerman instead of the other way around. And as Reason Contributing Editor Walter Olson notes in a recent essay, anyone who is concerned about racial disparities in the justice system should think twice before responding to Zimmerman’s acquittal by supporting legal changes that would make it easier to convict people and send them to prison.

It may be risky drawing any firm conclusions from these numbers, since self-defense claims involving the use of lethal force are pretty rare. The Times found a total of 192 such cases since 2005, or less than 20 a year, which is less than 2 percent of all homicides in Florida. When you get into subgroup analyses, the numbers are tiny. For example, the Times identified “only 26 completed cases in which a black person was killed and only eight fatalities with a Hispanic victim.”

The other thing to note about these cases is that it’s not clear to what extent, if at all, the new features of Florida’s law, such as eliminating the duty to retreat for people attacked outside their homes, affected the outcomes. It is therefore misleading to call them “stand your ground” cases, as the Times does.

 [Thanks to John Banzhaf for the tip.]


We encourage you to Share our Reports, Analyses, Breaking News and Videos. Simply Click your Favorite Social Media Button and Share.

Report abuse


Your Comments
Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green

Top Stories
Recent Stories



Top Global

Top Alternative



Email this story
Email this story

If you really want to ban this commenter, please write down the reason:

If you really want to disable all recommended stories, click on OK button. After that, you will be redirect to your options page.