Creating White Dwarf Star Stuff In The Laboratory: A Modern Day Prometheus

 
Credit: University of Texas

When the Z Machine fires, it releases more than six times the energy of all the power plants on Earth combined. Left: The center bay of the Z Machine is prepared for each “shot.” Right: The “tongues of dragon flame” captured in this image are the leaked charge that emerges from the Z Machine when it fires. Images courtesy of Sandia National Laboratories.

For a few nanoseconds, the power and density of the current is so great — more than six times the total amount of energy released by all the power plants in the world — that it vaporizes the wires, generating a gas-like substance known as hydrogen plasma. It simultaneously produces a magnetic field powerful enough to cause the plasma to implode.

For that brief nanomoment, as the magnetism “pinches” the plasma, generating a massive burst of X-radiation, Winget has a chunk of white dwarf star of his very own.

With this “star stuff,” Winget and his colleagues are poised to solve many of the mysteries of white dwarfs, which are extremely dense stars that are the ultimate end state of most stars in the universe, including our sun.

They’ll also use that knowledge to gain insight into the archaeological history of star formation in our galaxy, the nature of dark matter, and the conditions at the center of our sun, where the density is close to that of a white dwarf.

The experiments may even help push humanity closer to the dream of nuclear fusion as a meaningful energy source.

Image courtesy of Alexander Wang.

“If we can solve this, it will rattle through whole fields of astrophysics and physics,” says Winget.

Until very recently, if you’d asked Winget whether he’d like to make some white dwarf stuff in the lab, his answer would have been simple: Lovely idea. Not going to happen.

“For decades I’d been telling students that what I do is purely an observational science,” says Winget, a professor in theDepartment of Astronomy and a pioneer in the study of white dwarfs. “It’s not an experimental science.”

Then Winget was approached by Jim Bailey, a physicist atSandia National Laboratories in Albuquerque, N.M. Bailey was working with the facility’s Z Machine, which is the largest X-ray generator in the world.

The machine was primarily used to model nuclear weapons and investigate the potential of nuclear fusion as an energy source. But Bailey and Greg Rochau, also of Sandia, had begun to run experiments to see whether it could be used to simulate the conditions of stars.

“The environment we experience everyday on this planet is extraordinarily rare in the universe, if not unique,” says Rochau, manager of imaging and spectroscopy at Sandia. “Even though we think of these experiments as studying ‘extreme’ states of matter, the goal was actually to give us a small window into what the universe considers to be quite normal.”

White dwarfs are extremely dense stars that are the ultimate end state of most stars in the universe, including our sun.

This image from the Hubble Space Telescope shows Sirius A, the brightest star in our nighttime sky, along with its white dwarf companion, Sirius B (the tiny dot in the lower left).   White dwarfs typically have about the mass of the sun packed into a volume the size of the earth. 

Image courtesy of NASA, ESA. Credit: H. Bond (STScI) and M. Barstow (University of Leicester).

Some of the light signatures Bailey and Rochau were generating looked familiar to Winget and his group, who quickly realized that with the machine they could make plasmas with the same conditions as those found at the surface — the photosphere — of a white dwarf star. They could make an actual bit of white dwarf star in the lab.

They all agreed to pursue this idea, and on April 14, 2010, Winget stepped across the threshold from being an observational to an experimental scientist.

“I stood next to the door, saw the flash, heard the boom, and felt the seismic wave,” he wrote in an email, sent that day, to his colleague Ed Nather. “Today you, and everyone else on the planet, were closer to a white dwarf photosphere than anyone has ever been … the spectrograph was 5cm away — much better than 30-700 light years we are used to!”

For the past few years astronomer Don Winget has been using the Z Machine, the world’s largest x-ray generator, to create white dwarf “star stuff” here on earth. When he put a photograph of the Z Machine up on the projector, in his Astronomy 301 course, it inspired fine arts student Leah Flippen to begin a painting of the same name. In this video Winget and Flippen talk about the machine, the painting, and the interplay between science and art. 

For the past few years astronomer Don Winget has been using the Z Machine, the world’s largest x-ray generator, to create white dwarf “star stuff” here on earth. When he put a photograph of the Z Machine up on the projector, in his Astronomy 301 course, it inspired fine arts student Leah Flippen to begin a painting of the same name. In this video Winget and Flippen talk about the machine, the painting, and the interplay between science and art. 

For Winget it was a moment that transcended science (watch video)..

“I get this feeling of awe in my life on two occasions,” he says. “One is when I go to the telescope at the McDonald Observatory at night. I feel like I’m flying a spaceship through the universe, searching for things no one has ever seen before. The other is at the Z Machine when that shot goes off. There is no way to miss the power that is happening.”

The science was nice too. Until that point, Winget and his colleagues in the field of “asteroseismology” had developed a very precise tool to infer what the insides of white dwarfs were like based on the pulsations of the light that traveled from the stars through space to humanity’s telescopes.

“It’s like how sometimes you can hear one note, and you can say, ‘That’s Carlos Santana,’ ” says Winget. “That is what we do with the inside of the star. The star shakes from its own intrinsic pulsations, from turbulent convection at the surface of the star, and we take those frequencies and learn about everything below the surface.”

With this method the field had learned a great deal, but there were limits to what could be inferred from distant observation. The density of the hydrogen plasma surface of the star, in particular, was making it hard to properly interpret the light signatures.

“The surface of a white dwarf is on the order of 10,000 times more dense than the surface of our sun,” he says. “At these densities the whole is different than the sum of the parts.”

Without a good enough understanding of the physics of that surface, says Winget, it’s impossible to fully infer the conditions of the interior of the stars.

Image courtesy of Leah Flippen.

Related Video

The image of the Z Machine firing inspired UT studio art major Leah Flippen to create the painting on the right. Flippen saw the Z Machine photo during an Astronomy 301 course taught by Professor Winget. The finished painting will hang outside the actual Z Machine at Sandia Labs in New Mexico.

In this video, Winget and Flippen talk about the machine, the painting, and the interplay between science and art.