Explaining The Downfall Of Wintel And The Rise Of Google-tel?

i received several letters in response to my Deadbeat Carrier Series. Here are a few, along with my responses to them.

Reggie, I found what I think are some flaws in your carrier monthly cost numbers in your “Deadbeat Carriers Compete” blog posting. First the biggest flaw is that the $70 T-Mobile plan does NOT include unlimited hot spot service. It only includes 500mb of hot spot service. You can read it on this link from T-Mobile.com. http://www.t-mobile.com/shop/plans/individual-plans.aspx I couldn’t find the cost of 10gb of data including hot spot service but obviously it’s going to be more than $70/month.

This is only a problem if you do not embrace Android as your default OS, and Android 4.2.2 is quite capable of doing so for over 85% of computer users. See the video below…

{youtube}bB-icTl2J-c{/youtube}

{youtube}bB-icTl2J-c{/youtube}

Second, where are you getting the costs for AT&T? I went to their website and they don’t have minute plans that go up to 6000 minutes. Their individual plans are 450 minutes for $40, 900 minutes for $60 and unlimited minutes for $70 then you can add $20 for unlimited messaging. The data plans on the individual plans only go up to $50 for 5gb which includes hot spot service. They also have AT&T Mobile Share with unlimited talk and text plans which reduces the cost greatly from what you listed. Their 10gb mobile share plan costs $120/month and a single smartphone with that plan costs $30/month and you can use the hot spot service at that plan for no additional cost (I confirmed this with AT&T) so the total is $150/month (not $200 as you indicated).

AT&T has modified their pricing since I created the model, but the pricing has changed, not necessarily gotten cheaper. They effectively charge $10 per gigabyte for data, $70 for unlimited voice and $20 for unlimited texts. So 10 GB of data would be $100, and voice and text would be $90 combined – adding up to $190 before taxes, surcharges and fees which would add another nearly 20% on the price or roughly $220 total – as compared with T-Mobile whose package would be about $76 – all in (only sales tax is added in with pre-paid plans)! If one were to compare T-Mobile to the Mobile Share plan, there’s still a big discrepancy for the reader forgot to include surcharges, fees and taxes – again another nearly 20% tacked on, so we’re talking $180 per month, and that’s just with 10 gigs of data use. If one were to use 40 gigs like me, then you’d add another $36 per month on that – or roughly $216 which is pretty much where we started in the first place.

Lastly, where are you getting the costs for Verizon? Again, they appear to be way off. Verizon’s share everything plan with 10gb of data costs $100/month and then you add $40/month for single smartphone (with unlimited voice minutes and messages) and you can use the hot spot service at that plan for no additional cost so the total cost is $140/month (not $240/month as you indicated). I’m looking forward to your response. Thanks.

Again, the author is comparing family share plans to the single plan that was used in the model. Even so, Verizon pricing is far from a bargain. Let’s look closely at the numbers he provided. Verizon is charging the same as AT&T, $10 per gig, but charging more for the handset service @ $40. If one where to use 40 gigs per month, that would be $400 per month plus $40 for the handset plus the nearly 20% in taxes, fees and sucharges – all told over $500 per month, compared to the flat $76 from T-Mobile. Even if you used half the data, your looking at about $280.

As I said, deadbeat carriers. Here’s some more mails…

Reggie, Good postings. One of the reasons why I’m switching off from AT&T very shortly and going to T-Mobile. They just have the same offerings for a LOT less. Isn’t that what things were all about in the beginning before AT&T and Verizon slowly increased their prices and plans? On top of that one of the T-Mobile MVNO’s, Solavei, has been on the market for just under a year now I believe and Solavei offers things for $49 “ünlimited.” They’re main offering is working it into a MLM/referral-based program where a few referrals can chop the bill to 0 or make a few bucks. Worst case it’s good for a while before that program crashes possibly, then just jump back to T-Mobile (or other pre-paid style plans that offer nearly the same data and specs for less) Keep up the good work.

And here’s another one…

Reggie,