Excluding "FCANCER" Personalized License Plate Violates First Amendment
So Judge Gregory Williams (D. Del.) held today, in Overington v. Fisher: Even if FCANCER is understood as meaning “Fuck Cancer” (rather than, say, “Fight Cancer”), the exclusion of “any plate considered offensive in nature” from the state’s personalized plate program was unconstitutionally viewpoint-based and discretionary.
To reach this result, the judge had to decide whether the plates in the personalized plate program were private speech or government speech, and concluded that they were government speech. The court’s analysis was close to the one I wrote about two years ago in this post about Ogilvie v. Gordon (N.D. Cal.).
Seems generally correct to me. Perhaps a narrow and specific prohibition on particular vulgarities might be viewpoint-neutral (even if content-based), and thus permissible in a “limited public forum” such as this one; but a ban on “any plate considered offensive in nature” doesn’t qualify, see Iancu v. Brunetti (2019).
One error I noticed: The court cited Ogilvie for the proposition that “[O]bscenity, vulgarity, profanity, hate speech, and fighting words fall outside the scope of the First Amendment’s protections”; but Ogilvie didn’t hold that, and there are no First Amendment exception for vulgarity, profanity, or hate speech. Moreover, because “hate speech” is a viewpoint-based category (cf. Matal v. Tam (2017)), the government can’t exclude “hate speech” even from limited public fora (or nonpublic fora), even if it could exclude “vulgarity” or “profanity.”
The post Excluding “FCANCER” Personalized License Plate Violates First Amendment appeared first on Reason.com.
Source: https://reason.com/volokh/2024/05/14/excluding-fcancer-personalized-license-plate-violates-first-amendment/
Anyone can join.
Anyone can contribute.
Anyone can become informed about their world.
"United We Stand" Click Here To Create Your Personal Citizen Journalist Account Today, Be Sure To Invite Your Friends.
Humic & Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex
HerbAnomic’s Humic and Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex is a revolutionary New Humic and Fulvic Acid Complex designed to support your body at the cellular level. Our product has been thoroughly tested by an ISO/IEC Certified Lab for toxins and Heavy metals as well as for trace mineral content. We KNOW we have NO lead, arsenic, mercury, aluminum etc. in our Formula. This Humic & Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral complex has high trace levels of naturally occurring Humic and Fulvic Acids as well as high trace levels of Zinc, Iron, Magnesium, Molybdenum, Potassium and more. There is a wide range of up to 70 trace minerals which occur naturally in our Complex at varying levels. We Choose to list the 8 substances which occur in higher trace levels on our supplement panel. We don’t claim a high number of minerals as other Humic and Fulvic Supplements do and leave you to guess which elements you’ll be getting. Order Your Humic Fulvic for Your Family by Clicking on this Link , or the Banner Below.
Our Formula is an exceptional value compared to other Humic Fulvic Minerals because...
It’s OXYGENATED
It Always Tests at 9.5+ pH
Preservative and Chemical Free
Allergen Free
Comes From a Pure, Unpolluted, Organic Source
Is an Excellent Source for Trace Minerals
Is From Whole, Prehisoric Plant Based Origin Material With Ionic Minerals and Constituents
Highly Conductive/Full of Extra Electrons
Is a Full Spectrum Complex
Our Humic and Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex has Minerals, Amino Acids, Poly Electrolytes, Phytochemicals, Polyphenols, Bioflavonoids and Trace Vitamins included with the Humic and Fulvic Acid. Our Source material is high in these constituents, where other manufacturers use inferior materials.
Try Our Humic and Fulvic Liquid Trace Mineral Complex today. Order Yours Today by Following This Link.
| Online: | |
| Visits: | 1,613,553,542 |
| Stories: | 8,180,176 |
Whistler Blowers, Insiders
