Read the story here. Advertise at Before It's News here.
Profile image
By Post America American
Contributor profile | More stories
Story Views
Last hour:
Last 24 hours:

Jews Must Oppose Trump’s Immigration Policy (And Whites Should Feel Guilt)

% of readers think this story is Fact. Add your two cents.

Chemi Shalev: American Jews must oppose Trump’s immigration policy 


August 21, 2015  16 Comments

Kevin MacDonald


Haaretz columnist, Chemi Shalev, complains that Jewish organizations have not been up in arms about Donald Trump’s proposed immigration policy. The reason Jewish organizations must act is because over 90 years ago the US passed an immigration restriction bill that shut off the flow of Eastern European Jews to America.

The basic logic here is that the 1924 Immigration Restriction Act was the Original Sin of White America. The attempt on the part of Americans to fashion their immigration policy to retain an ethnic status quo as of 1890 was so horrifically evil that Jewish organizations have a duty to once again bring all the pressure they can muster to allow in every last immigrant who wants to come to America. Needless to say, Israel’s immigration policy — clearly engineered to retain Jewish ethnic dominance — is not at issue for Shalev.

I won’t dispute Shalev’s point that the main concern of White America in 1924 was the influx of Jews, but of course he fails to contextualize this concern properly. As I noted elsewhere, there was an:



Thus a main concern in addition to the very large numbers of radicals among Jewish immigrants and the fact that sympathy for the far left was entirely mainstream within the Jewish community,  was that Jews were fast becoming an intellectual elite with very different attitudes than the traditional people of America. These concerns are more than justified given the subsequent history of the US, and particularly US immigration policy where Jewish organizations led the campaign culminating in the 1965 immigration law that ended the ethnic status quo legislated by the 1924 law and opened up immigration to all the peoples of the world.

Unlike the 1924 law, the 1965 immigration law was not at all in response to public outcry but to prolonged pressure that was organized, funded and led by the organized Jewish community; it also occurred in the context of the ascendancy of Jewish-dominated intellectual movements that undercut the intellectual basis for immigration restriction rooted in the legitimate ethnic interests of the traditional people of America (see herepassim).

Since 1965, the mainstream Jewish community has strongly supported increasing the numbers of immigrants, as for example in their support of the Schumer-Rubio immigration amnesty/surge immigration bill in 2013. During the public debate, Jewish organizations once again flogged the 1924 law as the epitome of evil.

The immigration policy advocated by Jewish organizations for the US has always had two main components:

  • Maximize the total number of immigrants; in the immediate aftermath of the passage of the 1965 law that removed the bias toward Western Europe, Jewish immigration activists switched to focus on maximizing total numbers.  (See here, p. 291)
  • Promote the idea that immigrants not be chosen for their ability to make an economic contribution to the U.S. The assumption is that, apart from those who are “dangerous or a threat to national security,” all immigrants in whatever numbers have a positive impact on the society as a whole  (see previous link, p. 277-278). Family reunification, which has been a bedrock Jewish attitude at least since the 1940s (see previous link, p. 277-278),  is the basis of chain migration which has been one of themain reasons why numbers of immigrants has skyrocketed.

So that leaves us with Shalev’s concerns about the relative silence of Jewish organizations:



I rather doubt the latter reason is at all likely, and I won’t comment further on the glaring intellectual blind spot shown by Shalev where it’s morally okay for his people to have an ethnostate but anathema for European Americans.

However, it is interesting that Jewish organizations have remained relatively silent. As noted regarding the 2013 immigration debates, Jewish organizations were not at all shy about advocating the immigration amnesty/surge bill, finding their rationale in a supposed uniquely Jewish morality while making moral condemnations of its opponents.

It makes sense to suppose that since Jewish organizations are very publicly opposing Obama’s Iran deal, it might seem poor strategy to have Jewish organizations taking sides against Trump. One issue at a time. Also, there may well be a strand of Jewish thinking that any Republican would be relatively good for Israel given the unanimity of Republican opposition to the Iran deal. Still, I really can’t believe that Jewish activists would be bothered by a second Clinton presidency given her support among fanatical  Zionists like Haim Saban and her coterie of neocon foreign policy people.

Further, the immigration debate will be with us long after the vote on the Iran deal in September. Plenty enough time to pull out all the heavy artillery for the 2016 election. After all, lots of pundits are still predicting that Trump will be forgotten as a candidate in a few months. And from their point of view, the nomination and then resounding, often-predicted defeat of a Republican populist candidate would be cause for great rejoicing—a resounding defeat for the traditional people and culture of America.

Also, Trump’s policy statement has been roundly criticized in the mainstream media which has long reflected the views on immigration of the organized Jewish community. Here it would be silly not to mention Jews as media owners, media producers, and as able to expunge voices that violate the current racial zeitgeist (see here and here).

In a real sense, much of the mainstream media functions as a proxy for the views of the organized Jewish community; proxies have a similar effect but have the advantage of not calling attention to Jewish identities and interests. As Patrick Cleburne notes in a comment on the thousands that are expected to turn out for a Donald Trump rally in Mobile, Alabama:



Implicit in this statement is that Jewish concerns about White people turning into Nazis dominate the mainstream media. And although the media’s comparisons will be with Nazi rallies, it will be their proxies in the media making the comparisons, not Jewish organizations — at least for the time being.


This calls attention to the fact that Jewish organizations would do well not to take a public stance on Trump simply because he has touched a public nerve. It’s one thing to ruin careers of people with relatively little power, but certainly Trump is not so easily dealt with given his celebrity status, his wealth, and what increasingly seems to be his political deftness. The weakness of Jewish power is that, despite Jewish influence on the media, it has typically opposed strong trends in traditional American culture (public presence of Christianitygun controlthe public culture of homosexuality) that remain popular with substantial percentages of the public despite Jewish media influence.

This is also true of immigration. Despite the tsunami of positive messages on immigration emanating from the mainstream media, Trump’s policies on immigration are clearly in sync with the views of most Americans. Jewish attitudes on immigration are certainly not deeply rooted in popular attitudes among White Americans. The anti-White revolution has been a top-down phenomenon which has occurred because fundamentally America is now an oligarchy, not a democracy. Trump’s populist appeal is a real threat to our new, hostile elite because it is fundamentally uncontrollable.

In addition, it is quite possible that another reason for the relative silence is that the aura of Jewish moral superiority that has been so important for Jewish success has been slipping noticeably lately. This has occurred particularly on the left with the success of the BDS movement because of the behavior of Israel toward the Palestinians, and anyone who is remotely familiar with Israel is quite aware of Jewish double standards and hypocrisy on immigration as a moral imperative.

The loss of the Jewish image of victimhood and moral superiority would indeed be a very large step in the right direction. If and when Jewish organizations feel that it would be counterproductive to issue statements supporting immigration, it would be a great sign that things really are changing. I rather doubt that we are there yet, but their aura of moral superiority has never been so vulnerable.


Before It’s News® is a community of individuals who report on what’s going on around them, from all around the world.

Anyone can join.
Anyone can contribute.
Anyone can become informed about their world.

"United We Stand" Click Here To Create Your Personal Citizen Journalist Account Today, Be Sure To Invite Your Friends.

Please Help Support BeforeitsNews by trying our Natural Health Products below!

Order by Phone at 888-809-8385 or online at M - F 9am to 5pm EST

Order by Phone at 866-388-7003 or online at M - F 9am to 5pm EST

Order by Phone at 866-388-7003 or online at M - F 9am to 5pm EST

Humic & Fulvic Trace Minerals Complex - Nature's most important supplement! Vivid Dreams again!

HNEX HydroNano EXtracellular Water - Improve immune system health and reduce inflammation.

Ultimate Clinical Potency Curcumin - Natural pain relief, reduce inflammation and so much more.

MitoCopper - Bioavailable Copper destroys pathogens and gives you more energy. (See Blood Video)

Oxy Powder - Natural Colon Cleanser!  Cleans out toxic buildup with oxygen!

Nascent Iodine - Promotes detoxification, mental focus and thyroid health.

Smart Meter Cover -  Reduces Smart Meter radiation by 96%! (See Video).

Report abuse


    Your Comments
    Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green

    Total 15 comments
    • beyondsec

      Most Jews despise Zionism not because they are “self hating” Jews, but because we understand much of the world was deceived not by “Jews”, but those false NAZI ‘j’ews who wish to destroy Israel.

      I am White and Jewish, something you feel nothing but hatred for…our of ignorance.

      • they.pierced.My.hands.and.My.feet.

        Imagine having ‘presidents’ that profess to being “christian”, and simultaneously consent to the slaughter of millions of people around the earth. Talking about cog-dis on the unsuspecting ‘listeners’ who are deceived enough to ‘listen’ to wolves, as though wolves should be given a place.

        There are ‘christians’ who are not true children of Father Almighty.

        Same type deception.

    • Factory Farms FEAR the MooCow

      The evil people want you to….
      Eat More GMO :mad:

    • sean michael blacab

      Karma what the jews have done to others will be done to them.
      If you have done nothing, nothing will be done to you.
      Have a nice ride cowards.


    • Anonymous

      Israel ….. the most BIGOTED and RACIST WELFARE RECIPIENT on Earth.
      Israel is the only country that doesn’t have to be multicultural yet the Jewish controlled American congress and big business demands it of America – meanwhile our country is quickly starting to look very third world. Its time to stop this now – AIPAC owns the American congress. I’m speaking as a non-muslim American here. America needs a third viable political party that is going to represent the rights of middle class Americans. AIPAC secures $4BILLION of American taxpayers money to fund Israel’s war of genocide against the Palestinians. Some of that $4BILLION also returns to America in the form of BRIBES to “our”politicians. Christian American youth are dying in the middle east for Israel and don’t even know what they are fighting for – they think its for a terrorist threat to America. What idiots we are – wake up America and take your country back from both AIPAC and the government that has been bought by them. Israel is a tick on our back…lets take back our country.
      Who pushed America to help Bosnia against SERBIA….the Jews of course.
      In 2003, the Israeli Knesset passed the Nationality and Entry into Israel Law, which bars Palestinians from the West Bank and Gaza who are married to Palestinian citizens of Israel from living in Israel.

      • The Real Deal

        Comment of the day! Well said.

    • eXChroma

      Not gonna feel guilty kicking people out of America when they came to the country illegally. The country literally wasn’t a place for them to be unless they go through proper procedures and pass the tests, but they refused to do that, and willingly broke into our country. They should have no complaints if they were killed for it, they know what they did. Kicking them out with a slap on their wrist is a pathetic excuse for a punishment for them.

    • Donovan

      Joos smoos, I am sick and tired of this stupid debate or whatever. Jews are converts MADE UP of mostly prominent white Japhethic people. If you goy Japhethic white people can’t see the difference than you are blind! THERE IS NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A JEW AND A GENTILE!!! In simpler terms Jews=white Japheth, goy=white Japheth. Until you wake up to this big deception, they will continue claiming to be a Shemite race and crying antisemte nonsense.
      Shemites are the Oriental Hebrew. Chinese, Japanese, Mongolian, Native American, Island peoples, etc.

      • The Real Deal


        Really, genius? Then why do you Jews all cry anti-semitism all the time if there’s no difference between the two? Does that mean I can cry anti-semitism too every time a stinking Jew says something I don’t like? dumbest comment I’ve seen in a long time.

        And no, Jews and Gentiles are not the same. A Jew is a Jew is a Jew, this good cop/bad cop crap has been way overplayed. “Oh there’s Zionists, and then regular Jews”. Shut up. They’re are a very finite number of Jews who are against the Israeli occupation, and understand that Israel is not supposed to exist as a country. The rest are pro-Israeli, Anti-Gentile cretins.

        • Donovan

          Listen brighteyes, You’re beloved Amerika is already sold out and you keep on crying boo, hoo, the Jews did this or that. For all we know Donald Trump could be a Jew, too! You goy(cattle) deserve to be called that, because you don’t believe that Jews are masquerading as another people’s race. They are MADE UP of mostly Japhethite converts and claim to be semites if that is a name. If you want you could play Jew boy too.
          You didn’t explain anything I hadn’t heard. I will show you Biblically where it says in the Holy Word that Oriental are the Shem lineage. More than a Jew can say, they only have the talmud, where as the Hebrew Orientals have the Holy Bible. We are receiving the Holy Bible back, because your Japheth race doesn’t want it anymore, anyhow. :smile: Peace

    • U-No-Me

      I feel so guilty that I could celebrate!!!!!!!

    • TC

      Go to where Brother Nathanael shows how Trump is a Zionist stooge just like the others. If you don’t want a Zionist in charge, you have no horse in this race.

      • YourNumbr1Fan

        The fact that you can promote this JEW (I don’t give a DAMNED that he calls himself a Christian and dances around like a lunatic!) as a source of actual truth shows how asleep YOU are. THERE ARE NO GOOD JEWS. PERIOD. If they speak some truth, it’s ONLY to conceal bigger lies.

        You want some REAL truth, listen to Dr. David Duke… or YouTuber Scott Roberts…. or Red Ice Radio… or get it from some of these good websites:

        NEVER believe ANY Jew….. whether or not he calls himself a “brother” or “pastor” or anything else. They are ALL e.n.e.m.i.e.s. of Caucasian people. Period!

      • YourNumbr1Fan

        Forgot another good source of real truth:

        (again, stay away from “real JEW news”, dude.)

    Load more ...




    Email this story
    Email this story

    If you really want to ban this commenter, please write down the reason:

    If you really want to disable all recommended stories, click on OK button. After that, you will be redirect to your options page.