No Right Turns: Is Cashman Steering Yankees Lineup Into A Lefty Dead End?

In the latest episode of “what the hell is Brian Cashman doing now?” we focus on the next player that the Yankees acquired that isn’t what the Yankees really need. We have a long list of needs so in theory finding something to chase that isn’t what we need should be hard, right?

Not unless you are Cashman. He has this knack for dumpster diving for junk. I won’t even call it shopping in the clearance section because even the clearance bin would be insulted. The Yankees need better relief pitching, sound outfield depth, a catcher, the balls to dump Anthony Volpe and right handed hitting. None of that has happened….

But what has happened is the Yankees traded for Nationals First baseman Luis Garcia Jr. Who else is scratching their head right now besides me? It’s crazy and true and you can read more about it HERE. The Yankees certainly need a boost offensively because they are awful without Aaron Judge so the connection to Garcia Jr makes sense when he has a .283 BA this season. Dig a little deeper and stats show he has a .293 BA against right handed pitchers.

This team certainly needs offense. A guy that hits near 300 is great, but they Yankees need more of that. One guy isn’t going to bring the change this team needs without addressing positional needs also. But aside from that, it’s insane because this move doesn’t make sense. Adding another guy that plays first base is insane. He’s not an upgrade over Paul Goldschmidt and what about Ben Rice? That’s just another reason to make him more dispensable.

It’s just a giant log jam. He can play first base against a righty pitcher and then Rice can DH while Goldy rides the bench. When a lefty is on the mound, Goldy can play first and the Yankees can shuffle DH. That’s exactly what happens here. It’s a cluster-you-know-what and I say that because Garcia Jr has played second base and shortstop also but he was awful at both positions so it’s not like you can sit Jazz Chisholm or Volpe expecting an upgrade. It’s just a giant puzzle that Aaron Boone is gonna have to piece together every night and it’s one more opportunity for him to screw up. He was already good at that before adding another infielder to the equation so this could get even uglier.

Look am I glad Cashman finally woke up from his nap? Sure. I hate complacency. I wanted to see moves made more than anyone…..this one just doesn’t fix any of the Yankees major weaknesses. So without fixing those this accomplishes nothing. We don’t need another first baseman and we don’t need anymore left handed bats for crying out loud! Sorry, not sorry…..but I call it like I see it.